The Business Model Canvas: A Guide to Building a Resilient Company: A Big Dogs Network Leadership Conversation with Joe Carlucci

In a world where business success hinges on adaptability and strategic foresight, few leaders offer more practical wisdom than Joe Carlucci. This article, the second in a new monthly series from the Big Dogs Network, highlights insights from our recent conversation with Joe, founder of The Innovation Geek and former Director of Innovation Programming at Guidewell, a Blue Cross Blue Shield company in Florida. The Big Dogs Network is a professional network of business leaders and entrepreneurs with experience working for or with Fortune 1000 companies, dedicated to fostering collaboration, leadership, and continuous growth. Each month, we feature programming that delivers practical insights on business development and marketing, often led by luminaries in marketing, strategy, and innovation.

Joe helps companies and organizations practically apply innovation methods and systems to plan, build, and grow their short and long-term strategies. His journey is one of continuous exploration and a drive to find practical solutions to complex business challenges. Our conversation with him explored his expertise in "stress testing" a business model using the Business Model Canvas.

‍

A Better Way to “Stress Test” Your Business Model
‍

On August 28, 2025, Joe gave a presentation on how to "stress test" a business model using the Business Model Canvas. This powerful tool is a framework that helps you test new ideas, evaluate an existing business model, and clearly communicate the "what, why, and how" of a company’s operations. The core concept of the presentation was that the Business Model Canvas is not a typical static strategy document, but a “living document” meant to be continuously tested, iterated on, and refined over time.

Joe emphasized that the canvas is a collaborative, cross-functional exercise that brings together people from different departments who have diverse knowledge sets. It’s designed to be a quick and dirty tool that gets people thinking and working together. The process starts with a brainstorming session where stakeholders spend about ten minutes adding ideas to each section using sticky notes. Initially, it's a guesstimate, as you don't need to have all the answers. The real value of the model is in identifying the assumptions and hypotheses that need to be researched and tested to build a truly robust business.

The tool is divided into nine essential building blocks, which are categorized into three sections: desirability, feasibility, and viability. By examining each of these blocks, you can create a holistic view of your business and pinpoint areas of strength, weakness, and opportunity.

‍

1. Desirability (The “Front of the House”)
‍

This section represents everything the customer sees and experiences. It focuses on the fundamental question: will customers actually want and desire what you are offering? Joe stressed that you must always start here to ensure you're selling to the right customer with a compelling solution.

• Customer Segments: This block is about defining the people or organizations for whom you are creating value. It’s crucial to be specific. Are you targeting B2B or B2C clients? Are they a niche market or a broad audience? Understanding your customer segments is the foundation of your business model.
• Value Proposition: The value proposition is the heart of your business—the specific bundle of products and services that create value for each customer segment. This is not just a list of features; it's a description of how you solve a problem or fulfill a need for your customers. What makes your offering different and better than the competition?
• Channels: Channels are the touchpoints through which you will interact with customers and deliver your value proposition. This includes both communication channels (how you tell customers about your offering) and distribution channels (how you get the product or service to them). Think about your website, social media, physical stores, or partners.
• Customer Relationships: This block defines the types of relationships you will establish with your customers and how you will acquire and retain them. Will your relationship be personal and hands-on, or automated and self-service? How will you build loyalty and a sense of community?
• Revenue Streams: Documenting your revenue streams involves more than just a price list. It describes the pricing mechanisms and cash management through which your business captures value and gets paid. Will you use a subscription model, one-time sales, or something else entirely?

‍

2. Feasibility (The “Back of the House”)
‍

This part of the canvas deals with the internal infrastructure needed to create and deliver value. This section helps answer the critical "build-or-buy" question, which determines whether a company should develop capabilities in-house or partner with an outside organization.

• Key Resources: These are the indispensable assets required to make your business model work. This could include physical resources (a factory or office), intellectual property (patents or trademarks), human resources (a skilled team), or financial resources (capital).
• Key Activities: These are the most important things your business needs to perform exceptionally well to make the value proposition work. This could include manufacturing, marketing, problem-solving, or operational tasks.
• Key Partners: No company owns all the resources or performs all the activities itself. Key partners are the external entities that help you leverage your business model. These could be suppliers, strategic alliances, or joint ventures.

‍

3. Viability (The Bottom Section)
‍

The bottom section of the canvas addresses the most practical question of all: is the business model profitable?

• Cost Structure: This block outlines all the costs associated with running the business. This includes everything from fixed costs (rent, salaries) to variable costs (raw materials, production). By understanding your cost structure, you can determine if your revenue streams will be sufficient to generate a profit.

‍

Putting the Canvas into Practice: A Case Study
‍

To illustrate the power of the Business Model Canvas, Joe presented a case study from his previous role at a large healthcare payer. The company was seeking a new program to support expectant mothers at risk of postpartum depression. Instead of getting lost in a sea of ideas, they used the canvas to structure their thinking and create a clear, actionable plan.

The customer segment was defined as expectant mothers who might be at an elevated risk of postpartum depression. The value proposition was to use early detection and behavioral health to support maternal mental health, with PCPs playing a role in recommending care. To deliver this, they used channels and partnerships with a mental health app called Canopy and a company called Aeroflow for educational outreach. This was a critical "buy-build" decision, as they determined that it was far more efficient to partner with these existing experts than to build a mental health app and an outreach team from scratch.

The program began with a small pilot group of about 50 mothers to test the concept before expanding. Providers were considered as potential partners but ultimately not included in the initial rollout, as integration was seen as a major lift. During the brainstorming process, someone suggested white labeling the program for other payers—an idea that was parked for future consideration.

The revenue stream for the healthcare payer was not direct payment from the mothers, who received the service for free. Instead, the business model was viable because it focused on cost savings. The program successfully saved the payer an estimated $6.80 in ER and hospitalization costs for every dollar invested in the program. This demonstrates how the canvas helps you see the bigger picture beyond a simple transaction. The cost structure was a nominal fee for the partnership, which was also beneficial to Canopy and Aeroflow, as it gave them a powerful case study to take to other payers.

‍

The Canvas as a Living Document
‍

Joe emphasized that the Business Model Canvas is not just a planning tool but a dynamic framework for innovation. It's meant to be used throughout the year, with each block being a hypothesis that needs to be tested. The process follows a "build-test-measure" cycle, which involves creating a minimum viable product, testing it in the real world, and measuring the results to see if your hypothesis is correct. This continuous loop of testing allows a business model to adapt to external challenges such as changes in the industry, political climate, or technology. It helps you identify when an idea is not working so you can pivot or abandon it before sinking too many resources into a failed venture.

Joe noted that the tool is highly versatile: it can be applied to for-profits, nonprofits, and service delivery models alike. He also discussed how the canvas can help identify potential cannibalization scenarios, using Apple’s decision to launch the iPhone before the iPad as an example of managing value propositions strategically.

The Business Model Canvas is a valuable tool for anyone looking to build, test, and grow their short and long-term strategies. It provides a simple, visual, and effective way to map out and understand your business, ensuring that you are not just creating a great product, but a sustainable and successful business model. A workbook and additional resources were made available for those who attended the presentation, highlighting the practical application of the concepts discussed.

‍

Key Takeaways
‍

• The Business Model Canvas is a “living document” for continuous testing and iteration, not a static strategy plan.
• It is made up of nine building blocks divided into three sections: desirability (customer focus), feasibility (infrastructure focus), and viability (profitability focus).
• Joe recommends starting with desirability to ensure your solution is compelling to the right customers.
• The tool is a collaborative, cross-functional exercise designed to bring together diverse perspectives to test and improve business ideas, often facilitated in short, hands-on workshops.
• The "build-test-measure" cycle is a critical component of using the canvas, allowing you to validate or invalidate hypotheses and adapt to market changes.
• The canvas helps you identify your core assumptions and test them in the real world before committing significant resources to an unproven idea.

‍

Learn More
‍

The Big Dogs Network is all about sharing experiences, connections, and practical knowledge to help leaders grow and thrive. With a strong focus on strategies that resonate with Fortune 1000 companies, our programming is designed to offer actionable insights from those who have successfully navigated high-stakes business environments.

If you would like to learn more about the Big Dogs, please reach out to any of our leadership members:
Ron Synder (rsnyder@innovations86.com)
Peter Kay (pkay@innovations86.com)
Steve Bellach (steve@blmllc.com)
Kirsty Nunez (kirsty.nunez@q2insights.com)

If you would like to speak with Joe about the services he offers at The Innovation Geek, you can reach him at info@theinnovationgeek.com.

This article is the second in a monthly series highlighting key takeaways from Big Dogs events and conversations. Future articles will feature insights from other remarkable leaders with experience in Fortune 1000 companies offering strategies, lessons, and inspiration for today’s business challenges. We look forward to continuing this series with more conversations that inspire action and growth.

Article by Kirsty D. Nunez, President and Chief Research Strategist at Q2 Insights, and member of the Big Dogs Network leadership team.

‍